From: Ashu M. G.
Solo
Sent: Saturday, April 21, 2012 8:39 AM
To: Mayor's Office; Randy Donauer
Cc: Darren hill; Pat Lorje; Ann Iwanchuk; Myles Heidt; Charlie Clark; Mairin Loewen; Glen Penner; Tiffany Paulsen; Bev Dubois
Subject: Newspaper Article About Religious Bigotry at Saskatoon
Volunteer Appreciation Banquet
FROM
This is on the
third page of the Star Phoenix and on the Star Phoenix Web site too.
Christian prayer sparks complaint
Citizen felt excluded by blessing
BY BETTY ANN ADAM, THE STARPHOENIX
A Christian prayer by a city councillor at a
City of Saskatoon volunteer appreciation dinner discriminated against
non-Christians, says a volunteer who intends to complain to the Saskatchewan
Human Rights Commission.
Ashu
Solo, a member of the city's cultural diversity and race relations committee,
was among the guests at the dinner Wednesday, where Coun. Randy Donauer said a
blessing over the food in which he mentioned Jesus and ended with
"amen."
"It
made me feel like a second-class citizen. It makes you feel excluded,"
said Solo, who is an atheist.
"It's
ironic that I've now become a victim of religious bigotry and discrimination at
this banquet that was supposed to be an appreciation banquet for the service of
volunteers like me."
The
inclusion of a Christian prayer at a municipal government event violates the
separation of religion and government, Solo wrote in a lengthy email to Mayor
Don Atchison, which he later distributed to the rest of council.
Solo also
takes issue with a prayer that "clearly gives primacy to one religion over
all other religions" at a municipal event paid for with Saskatoon taxpayer
money.
"This
is not a Christian country or a Christian city. It is a secular multicultural
country and secular multicultural city with people from numerous religions as
well as spiritual people, agnostics and atheists," Solo said.
Municipal
officials should not use their offices to "perform religious bigotry, as
this is," or "to impose their own religious beliefs on others,"
Solo said.
Atchison
said he was caught off-guard by the complaint because many of the events he
attends include a prayer before meals.
"I've
never given it any thought at all," he said.
Atchison
said he is sorry to hear Solo felt excluded.
He
suggested in the future, the dinner could feature prayers from different
religions on a rotating basis. There could even be a dinner with no prayer at
all for atheists, he said.
Solo said
the rotation idea will not work because there are thousands of religions.
He wants
an apology from the mayor and a promise there won't be any more prayers at City
of Saskatoon events. He said if he does not receive those by next Friday, he
will proceed with a human rights complaint naming the City of Saskatoon,
Atchison and Donauer.
"That
will give us a few days to think about it and see what we need to do
here," Atchison said. "I certainly couldn't give that (assurance and
apology) to anyone right now."
Donauer,
who is a parttime administrator at Saskatoon Christian Centre, an evangelical
church, said he doesn't see anything wrong with praying to Jesus at such an
event.
"If
I go to function, whether it's a different religious organization or community
organization, if they have a spiritual service, opening the function or
something like that, I've never been offended by that, I don't have a problem
with that. People are entitled to do what they want to do."
Asked if
a City of Saskatoon event is different from a religious community event,
Donauer responded, "I think he's got a different view on it than I do. I'm
for freedom and tolerance.
"Separation
of church and state is not a legislated thing. The charter of rights opens with
the line under "the supremacy of God," so in the first line of the
charter of rights of the Constitution it acknowledges that there is a God. So
how prayer can violate that is beyond me," he said.
badam@thestarphoenix.com
©
Copyright (c) The StarPhoenix